Google eyed by European Parliament Report on misleading and aggressive advertising

The European Parliament has approved a report recommending that the European Commission introduces new legislation to combat misleading and aggressive advertising. Although the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive already regulates this area, the Juvin Report highlights the danger of the growth of new, more pervasive forms of advertising being used on the internet.

Though there is no explicit mention of Google Inc, it is obvious that the proposals target some of the services offered by the internet giant. With a clear reference to Google’s AdWords service, the Report calls on the Commission to condemn the practice of allowing companies to bid for keywords associated with brand names in search engines. When an internet user enters a purchased keyword into a search engine, that company’s advertisement is displayed alongside the ‘natural’ search results. Since 2000, when AdWords was first released, Google has faced countless lawsuits in the US and across the EU over its service. Despite claims that selling brand names as keywords encourages acts of parasitism and counterfeiting, the European Court of Justice has upheld the practice as lawful so long as the associated ads do not mislead the user as to the identity of the advertiser. The Report proposes that keywords associated with registered trademarks should only be available if the owner of the trademark authorises such use of the brand in question.

Targeted advertising is also flagged up as an unfair advertising practice. With significant implications for Google’s Gmail service, the Report recommends the complete prohibition of third parties reading private emails for advertising purposes. It is suggested that such practices are intrusive and constitute an attack on the privacy of individual consumers. Besides Google, websites such as Trip Advisor could also come under fire if the proposals are taken up. The Report warns of the danger of ‘hidden advertising’ which takes place in forums where consumers post comments to one another about various goods or services. It recommends the creation of forum moderators, and suggests running a campaign to alert consumers about this form of advertising.

The Report is scheduled for a full vote in December.

Further reading

Read the Juvin Report

Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee press release

By Katey Dixon